
The voice that greets a caller on a telephone network belongs to somebody, and that somebody has rights. On 4 September 2026 the High Court of Tanzania at Dar es Salaam confirmed it in Lisa Steven Semgalawe v Vodacom Tanzania Public Limited Company, Aggrey & Clifford Limited and Tsere’s Co. Ltd, Civil Case No. 26033 of 2024, reported as [2026] TZHC 5238. Mbagwa J held that Vodacom Tanzania infringed Ms Semgalawe’s copyright in the Interactive Voice Response prompts (IVRs) she recorded, and that Vodacom was unjustly enriched by using them. The court ordered Vodacom to pay TZS 100,000,000 as general damages and TZS 20,000,000 as punitive damages, with court interest at 7% and costs.
Rive & Co acted for Ms Semgalawe. Vodacom lodged a notice of appeal on 2 October 2026, so this article reports what the High Court decided and does not predict what the Court of Appeal will do.
How a few hours in a studio became a High Court case
In February 2016, Aggrey & Clifford Limited, a supplier to Vodacom, approached Tsere’s Co. Ltd, a recording studio, to produce the voice prompts Vodacom needed for its network responses and M-Pesa. The studio, through its director Luciano Tsere, found Ms Semgalawe, a voice over artist. On 16 February 2016 she recorded twelve IVRs in Kiswahili and twelve in English. Vodacom reviewed the recordings and asked for improvements. She returned to the studio on 22 February 2016 and made the adjustments, and Vodacom accepted the final work.
She was paid TZS 1,800,000, which she said was the fee for the basic recording session. A Model Release Agreement, the document that sets out how the work may be used, was supposed to follow. It was never signed. Ms Semgalawe’s case was that Vodacom nevertheless went on using her voice on its network from 2016 until she sued in 2024, without her authorisation and without paying for that use.
What each side argued
Ms Semgalawe asked the court to declare that her copyright had been infringed and that the defendants were unjustly enriched. She claimed TZS 263,540,918,623 as damages, a 50% royalty on the benefits obtained, interest, punitive damages of TZS 200,000,000 and costs.
Vodacom said it owned the IVRs. Its case rested on a Master Procurement Agreement of 16 July 2014 with Aggrey & Clifford under which, it said, whatever the supplier developed became Vodacom’s property. It also filed a third party notice asking the court to order Aggrey & Clifford to indemnify it if Vodacom were found liable. Aggrey & Clifford said it was not a party to the agreement between Ms Semgalawe and the studio and that the indemnity dispute belonged in arbitration. The studio, in a way, agreed with Ms Semgalawe. It said the understanding was that Vodacom would sign the Model Release Agreement with her once the final versions were ready, and that this was not done.
The case was heard on witness statements. Ms Semgalawe called three witnesses and tendered five exhibits, including her voice over services agreement of 16 February 2016, a forensic report of 17 September 2024 confirming that the recordings belong to her, her demand letter of 25 April 2024 and Vodacom’s reply of 27 May 2024, and a report on the analysis of compensatory damages. Five defence witnesses testified.
The six issues the court decided
The court framed six issues and answered them in turn.
- Was Ms Semgalawe the author and owner of the IVRs?
- If so, did Vodacom infringe her copyright?
- Did the defendants unjustly enrich themselves by using the IVRs?
- Was she entitled to the reliefs she sought?
- If Vodacom was liable, was Aggrey & Clifford obliged to indemnify it?
- What reliefs were the parties entitled to?
Ownership: the artist who records the work owns it
The court held that Ms Semgalawe is the author and owner of the IVRs. It was common ground that the recordings were her vocal work and that she recorded them in the studio. Section 17 of the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act, Cap. 218 R.E. 2023, recognises the author as the primary owner of the work, and the court held that her vocal expression is protected under section 5(1)(d).
The defendants could not produce any evidence that ownership, or permission to use the work, had passed from her to Aggrey & Clifford or to Vodacom. A Vodacom witness accepted in cross examination that Aggrey & Clifford would first need to obtain Ms Semgalawe’s rights before assigning them to Vodacom. The court noted that intellectual property is an asset like any tangible property, so a transfer of ownership or authority to use it has to be properly proved. The one payment of TZS 1,800,000, which the invoice showed was for the artist’s recording session, did not do that. The Master Procurement Agreement could not give Vodacom ownership that Aggrey & Clifford never had.
Infringement: authority has to be sought before use
Section 18 of the Act says that a person who intends to use a protected right must seek authorisation from the copyright holder. The court found that Vodacom did not prove it had done so. Vodacom did not deny using IVRs on its network. It argued that the IVRs it used were not Ms Semgalawe’s, but it called no one to say who else had recorded them, and the court drew a negative inference against it.
The court also found a constructive admission in Vodacom’s own reply to the demand letter. In it, Vodacom said the IVRs it used were products it had acquired lawfully from Aggrey & Clifford. The judge read that as an admission that Vodacom uses the IVRs, and held that the rest of the evidence was enough to prove they are Ms Semgalawe’s, even without the forensic evidence. Vodacom was therefore held to have infringed her rights under sections 5, 9 and 18 of the Act.
Unjust enrichment: IVRs are part of a commercial service
Vodacom argued that IVRs earn it no money because customers do not pay for network prompts. The court was not persuaded. It was common ground that Vodacom uses the IVRs in providing its services, and those services are commercial. The court reasoned that the IVRs therefore contribute, even if indirectly, to the income Vodacom earns.
Because the point was new in Tanzania, the judge looked abroad. He referred to the South African Constitutional Court decision in Vodacom (Pty) Ltd v Makate and Another [2025] ZACC 13, where Vodacom’s ‘Please Call Me’ service was found to have commercial value, and to the United States Ninth Circuit decision in Midler v Ford Motor Co, 849 F.2d 460 (1988), where using a person’s voice to sell a product without authority was held to be a tort. The court held that by using the IVRs unlawfully Vodacom had unjustly enriched itself.
Damages: the large claim failed, the award stands
Section 39(1)(b) of the Act entitles a person whose rights have been infringed to damages. Ms Semgalawe’s claim for TZS 263,540,918,623 was a claim for specific damages, which have to be strictly proved. Her witness, a Certified Public Accountant, gave evidence on a report calculated from periodicity, subscriber base, the number of IVRs, how often they were used and a usage fee. The court was not satisfied with the data behind the report and held that the specific damages were not strictly proved.
That did not leave Ms Semgalawe without a remedy. Relying on the principle that where there is a wrong there is a remedy, the court held that Vodacom must compensate her because it infringed her rights and gained financially from doing so. In awarding TZS 100,000,000 as general damages, the judge took into account that Vodacom had used the IVRs since 2016 and that its service covers the whole country. He also awarded TZS 20,000,000 as punitive damages for deliberate infringement of her copyright.
The final orders against Vodacom were as follows.
- A declaration that Vodacom infringed Ms Semgalawe’s copyright and unjustly enriched itself by unlawfully using her voice over in the IVRs.
- General damages of TZS 100,000,000.
- Court interest at 7% on the general damages from the date of judgment to the date of full payment.
- Punitive damages of TZS 20,000,000.
- Costs of the case to be borne by Vodacom.
The indemnity claim and the arbitration clause
Vodacom’s third party notice against Aggrey & Clifford did not succeed. The Master Procurement Agreement does require the supplier to indemnify Vodacom, but clause 30 sends disputes under the agreement to arbitration. Following the Court of Appeal in Serengeti Breweries v Monaban Trading Farming Co Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 52 of 2023 (17 October 2025), the court held that it could not decide the indemnity question because the parties had not gone through arbitration. It held that Aggrey & Clifford is not obliged to indemnify Vodacom in this case, and entered judgment against Vodacom alone, since it was Vodacom that used the work without authorisation.
The point carries a lesson for every contract that contains an arbitration clause. If you want a court to order an indemnity, the arbitration route has to be followed first.
What this means for creators
Three practical points come out of the judgment. First, the artist who performs and records the work is its first owner, and a one off session fee is payment for the session, not a transfer of ownership or a licence to use the recording indefinitely. Second, authority to use a work has to be proved by the user, and an unsigned release agreement proves nothing. Third, a court will award damages even where the claimed figure cannot be proved to the standard the law requires, but a creator who wants a larger award has to bring reliable data on how widely and how often the work was used. Keep your invoices, emails and original files, and ask for the licence terms in writing before you record.
What this means for brands and agencies
A company that obtains content through a supplier cannot assume that the supplier’s contract gives it ownership. The question the court asked was whether the artist had ever parted with her rights, and the answer was no. Brands should ask suppliers for the chain of title, which means the signed release or licence from every performer, before a recording goes live. Supply agreements should include a warranty that the supplier holds all rights and an indemnity, and they should say clearly whether disputes go to court or arbitration.
Practical checklist
For creators:
- Sign a written release or licence that states the term, territory, media and fee for each use.
- If the work is to be used beyond the recording session, ask for a licence fee or royalty, not only a session fee.
- Keep copies of the recordings, invoices, emails and any forensic or technical evidence that the work is yours.
- Write to the user early, and take advice before the use becomes long running.
For brands and agencies:
- Obtain the signed release from every performer before using a recording.
- Audit existing prompts, jingles and voice overs for missing paperwork.
- Put a rights warranty and an indemnity in every supply contract, and follow the dispute resolution clause as written.
- Treat a creator’s demand letter as a legal matter from day one.
Where the case stands
The High Court judgment is the current position. Vodacom lodged a notice of appeal to the Court of Appeal of Tanzania on 2 October 2026. An appeal does not by itself stop a decree from being enforced, as Rule 11(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules, 2009 provides, although a party can apply for a stay. We will not comment on the merits of the appeal while it is pending.
Read the judgment
A copy of the judgment in Civil Case No. 26033 of 2024 is available for download below.You can also request it by email at sunday@rive.co.tz.
https://www.rive.co.tz/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/civil-decision-2026-09-08-11_15_57.pdf
https://www.rive.co.tz/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/civil-decree-2026-09-08-11_43_38.pdf
Frequently asked questions
Can a voice over artist own copyright in a recording in Tanzania?
Yes, where the recording is original and fixed in a material form. Who owns it and how it may be used then depends on the contract and on the Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act, Cap. 218 R.E. 2023.
What damages can a Tanzanian court award for copyright infringement?
Section 39 of the Act allows civil remedies, including damages and, in suitable cases, exemplary damages. The amount depends on the evidence of use, duration, reach and the benefit to the infringer.
What is the difference between general and punitive damages?
General damages compensate for loss. Punitive damages punish conduct and discourage repetition.
Is the decision final?
No. Vodacom has lodged a notice of appeal. Until the Court of Appeal decides, the High Court judgment stands.
Does a company that hires an agency avoid liability?
Not automatically. The brand that runs the content may still answer for the use if the rights were not properly cleared. The contract with the agency should allocate that risk, but it does not remove it against the creator.
How long do I have to bring a copyright claim in Tanzania?
Limitation periods apply and they differ depending on the nature of the claim, so take advice early. Do not wait for the use to end.
Who should I speak to if my work has been used without permission?
An advocate experienced in copyright disputes. Preserve the original files, contracts, payment records and screenshots or recordings of where the work was used.
About the author
Sunday Ndamugoba is a Partner at Rive & Co and heads the Corporate department. He is an advocate of the High Courts of Tanzania and Zanzibar, a UK Chartered Trademark Attorney, a registered arbitrator and an accredited mediator. Contact: sunday@rive.co.tz.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. It reflects the law and the High Court decision as at the date of publication, and the decision is subject to appeal. You should obtain advice on your own facts before acting. Rive & Co accepts no liability for reliance on this article. Rive & Co acted for the successful plaintiff in this matter.
