The fine is not calculated on the deal value. It is calculated on your turnover. That is the point most buyers miss when they decide the filing fee is too expensive and the transaction is too small to attract attention.

Section 60 of the Fair Competition Act, as amended, allows the Commission to impose a fine of not less than five percent and not exceeding ten percent of the annual turnover of the offender which has a source in Mainland Tanzania. The amendment clarified the geographic base. It did not soften the percentage. A profitable Tanzanian operating company with modest margins can face a penalty that exceeds several years of net profit for a filing it declined to make.

Tanga Fresh: the case that shows how it happens

In Tanga Fresh Limited v The Fair Competition Commission, Tribunal Appeal No. 5 of 2014, a dairy company acquired two businesses engaged in milk collection and dairy processing in the Tanga region, in 2011, without notifying the FCC. The FCC learned of the acquisitions, investigated, issued a statement of objection and provisional findings, and found that the company had failed to notify and had strengthened a dominant position.

The Commission imposed a fine of TZS 460,945,000, being five percent of the company’s annual turnover for 2009. That is the floor of the statutory range, not the ceiling.

The Tribunal’s reasoning is worth reading in full for three reasons.

  1. It rejected an argument built on ordinary dictionary meanings and the mischief rule, holding that competition law requires an economic rather than a purely linguistic interpretation of what a merger is.
  2. It drew on the International Competition Network Recommended Practices for Merger Notification and Review, which treat an acquisition of all or substantially all of a business’s assets as a notifiable merger. Asset deals are not a way around the regime.
  3. It rejected a failing firm defence on the evidence. If you intend to rely on the condition of the target, you need contemporaneous financial evidence, not assertion.

Scancem and Tanga Cement: conditions bite

The Tribunal’s consolidated decision in Appeals Nos. 6, 10 and 12 of 2022, arising from the FCC’s conditional approval of Scancem International DA’s acquisition of a controlling stake in Tanga Cement Plc, is the other decision every dealmaker in Tanzania should know.

Three parties appealed. A competitor, Chalinze Cement Limited. A consumer body, the Tanzania Consumer Advocacy Society. And the acquirer itself, which challenged the legal basis and the practical workability of several of the conditions the FCC had imposed.

The lessons are commercial rather than academic.

  1. Third parties have standing. Section 61(3) of the Act gives interested parties a route into the process. Your competitor can and will use the public comment window and the appeal process to slow you down.
  2. Conditional approval is the FCC’s default remedy in concentrated markets. The Commission tends towards behavioural conditions tailored to the sector rather than outright prohibition. Conditions are enforceable and they survive completion.
  3. The conditions themselves are negotiable at the review stage and expensive to challenge afterwards. Engage on remedies before the decision, not after.

What early implementation looks like in practice

Failure to notify is the obvious breach. The subtler one is implementing a notified merger before clearance. Conduct that has attracted scrutiny in comparable jurisdictions and that the FCC treats as implementation includes the following.

  1. Registering the share transfer or updating the register of members before clearance.
  2. Appointing the buyer’s nominees to the target board, or giving them observer rights with influence over decisions.
  3. Requiring the target to obtain the buyer’s consent for ordinary course decisions during the interim period.
  4. Integrating sales teams, pricing, procurement or IT before clearance.
  5. Exchanging current and forward looking pricing, customer and margin data outside a clean team arrangement.

Interim covenants in a sale and purchase agreement are legitimate where they protect the value of the business between signing and completion. They become a problem where they hand operational control to the buyer in advance.

Voluntary disclosure

The FCC has dealt with a number of unnotified mergers, some discovered through its own investigations and some disclosed voluntarily by the parties after the fact. Where a transaction has already closed without notification, the position is not improved by waiting. A structured voluntary disclosure, with a clear account of why the parties took the view they did and what the competitive effect has been, puts you in a materially better position than an FCC investigation that starts with a complaint from a competitor.

Frequently asked questions

What is the penalty for not notifying a merger to the FCC in Tanzania?
A fine of not less than five percent and not exceeding ten percent of the offender’s annual turnover which has a source in Mainland Tanzania, under section 60 of the Fair Competition Act as amended.

Can the FCC unwind a completed transaction in Tanzania?
The FCC has powers to act against mergers implemented in breach of the Act, and clearance is a precondition to giving effect to a notifiable merger. Parties should not assume that completion cures the failure to notify.

Is an asset purchase notifiable in Tanzania?
Yes. The definition of merger expressly covers the acquisition of a business or other assets, and the Tribunal in Tanga Fresh confirmed that acquiring all or substantially all of a business’s assets is a notifiable merger.

We closed six months ago and never filed. What now?
Take advice on a voluntary disclosure. Quantify the exposure against Tanzanian sourced turnover first so the decision is made on numbers rather than instinct.

Can a competitor object to our merger in Tanzania?
Yes. The FCC publishes merger notifications and invites petitions from parties with sufficient interest, and interested third parties have appealed FCC decisions to the Fair Competition Tribunal.

Written by Sunday Ndamugoba, Partner and Head of the Corporate Department at RIVE & Co. Advocates and Legal Consultants, Advocate of the High Courts of Tanzania and Zanzibar. sunday@rive.co.tz

Disclaimer: This article is general information and not legal advice. Decisions of the Fair Competition Tribunal are summarised for illustration and should be read in full before being relied upon. Obtain specific advice on your transaction.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *