
The single most consequential decision a Tanzanian taxpayer makes after receiving an adverse assessment is not whether to object — it is how to fund the deposit required to keep the objection alive. The one-third tax deposit rule under the Tax Administration Act, Cap. 438, has sunk many otherwise meritorious disputes. This article unpacks the rule, the waiver discretion, and the binding precedent set by the Court of Appeal.
The Statutory Anchor: Section 51 of the Tax Administration Act
Under section 51(5) of the Tax Administration Act, a notice of objection shall not be admitted unless the taxpayer has paid the greater of:
- The amount of tax not in dispute; or
- One-third of the assessed tax.
For customs duty or any tax assessed on imports, the whole sum must be paid before the objection bites. This is a strict pre-condition — without payment (or a waiver), the objection legally does not exist.
The Waiver Application: Section 51(7) and (8)
The Commissioner General may, upon written application by the taxpayer, waive or reduce the deposit. The application must be made within fifteen (15) days of issue of the tax decision. The taxpayer must demonstrate “good reason” — typically:
- Genuine inability to pay (with audited financials, cash-flow forecasts and bank statements);
- That payment would cause irreversible commercial prejudice (insolvency, loss of going-concern status);
- That the assessment is so manifestly excessive that one-third would itself be substantially more than the tax that should ever be payable.
Lessons from Pan African Energy Tanzania Ltd v. TRA
The Court of Appeal’s decision in Pan African Energy Tanzania Ltd v. Commissioner General TRA, Civil Appeal No. 121 of 2018, remains the leading authority. Three principles emerge:
- The Commissioner General’s discretion to waive is real but narrow — “good reason” is judged against a high bar.
- The TRAB and TRAT have jurisdiction to hear an appeal arising from a refusal to grant a waiver, but the appellant must invoke the correct enabling provision.
- The clock for admission of the objection only begins after the deposit (or reduced deposit, where granted) is paid.
In Pan African Energy, the Board reduced the deposit to 5% of the assessed amount in the interest of justice — a pragmatic outcome later upheld by the Tribunal and accepted by the Court of Appeal.
Practical Strategies for Funding the Deposit
- Bank guarantee: in some files the TRA has accepted a bank guarantee as security in lieu of cash, particularly for foreign-owned subsidiaries with strong parent backing;
- Phased payment: negotiate a payment schedule contemporaneously with the waiver application;
- Restructuring the dispute: if the assessment groups several heads of tax, segregating them may reduce the “assessed tax” denominator on the head you intend to dispute;
- Early settlement engagement: the proposal-letter / mediation routes can reduce the principal before the deposit clock matters.
What Happens if You Pay and Win?
Where the objection or appeal is successful, the deposit is refundable with interest computed at the statutory rate (currently the Bank of Tanzania discount rate plus 5% per annum, compounded monthly). The deposit remains with the Commissioner General throughout the appeals chain — TRAB, TRAT, Court of Appeal — and is released only on final determination.
RIVE & Co.’s Approach
We treat the deposit question as a strategic problem, not just a compliance step. Our team designs funding structures, drafts persuasive waiver applications, and litigates refusals where the discretion has been improperly exercised. We have particular experience handling deposit disputes for clients in extractives, telecoms, banking, and real estate.
Facing a one-third deposit you cannot fund?
Reach me at sunday@rive.co.tz — every day matters.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The law is stated as at the date of publication and may change. Readers should seek specific legal advice before acting on any matter discussed. RIVE & Co. and the author accept no liability for action taken or not taken on the basis of this publication.
