
An objection decision from the Commissioner General is not the end of the road. Tanzania’s tax appeal architecture, governed by the Tax Revenue Appeals Act, Cap. 408, gives taxpayers three further forums in which to vindicate their position: the Tax Revenue Appeals Board (TRAB), the Tax Revenue Appeals Tribunal (TRAT), and the Court of Appeal of Tanzania. The architecture is generous in principle but punitive in procedure: miss a deadline by a single day and the entire appeal collapses.
Forum One: The Tax Revenue Appeals Board (TRAB)
The TRAB is established under section 4 of the Tax Revenue Appeals Act. It comprises a Chairman, three Vice-Chairmen (one from Tanzania Zanzibar) and not more than twelve other members appointed regionally by the Minister.
Under section 16 of the Act, any person aggrieved by an objection decision of the Commissioner General may appeal to the Board, provided that:
- A notice of appeal is served on the Commissioner General within thirty (30) days following the date on which the objection decision is served on the appellant; and
- The appeal itself is lodged with the Board within forty-five (45) days following the date on which the objection decision is served.
The proceedings before the TRAB are governed by the Tax Revenue Appeals Board Rules, 2018 (G.N. No. 217 of 2018). The Board hears matters of fact and law, takes oral evidence, and issues a reasoned written decision.
Forum Two: The Tax Revenue Appeals Tribunal (TRAT)
The TRAT is established under section 8 of the Tax Revenue Appeals Act and supervises the TRAB. A party aggrieved by a TRAB decision may appeal to the TRAT within thirty (30) days from the date of service of the decision and proceedings, with notice to the opposing party within fifteen (15) days from the date of service.
The Tribunal has the power to call for and inspect the records of the Board and to revise any decision. It conducts a fresh consideration of the matter on the record (and, where leave is granted, with new evidence).
Forum Three: The Court of Appeal of Tanzania
An appeal from the TRAT lies to the Court of Appeal of Tanzania, but only on questions of law. The Appellate Jurisdiction Act, Cap. 141, and the Court of Appeal Rules apply mutatis mutandis. This is the apex of the chain — the Court does not re-open factual findings made by the Board or Tribunal.
The Question of Jurisdiction: TRAB and the High Court
A long line of authority — most notably TRA v. Tango Transport Company Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 84 of 2009 — confirms that the High Court does not have original jurisdiction over substantive tax disputes. The TRAB is the gateway tribunal; the High Court’s role in tax matters is limited.
Tax Deposit Through the Appeals Chain
Section 16(6) of the Tax Revenue Appeals Act, read with section 51(5) of the Tax Administration Act, provides that any tax deposited at the objection stage shall remain deposited with the Commissioner General until final determination of the appeal. There is no further deposit at TRAB, TRAT or Court of Appeal stage — but interest continues to accrue on the disputed unpaid balance.
Extensions of Time
Section 16(5) gives the Board or Tribunal discretion to extend the limits of time where the failure to give notice, lodge an appeal, or effect service was occasioned by:
- Absence from the United Republic;
- Sickness; or
- Other reasonable cause,
subject to such terms and conditions as to costs as may be considered just.
Strategic Considerations
- Settlement at TRAB / TRAT stage: the Finance Act, 2021 introduced mediation; many large disputes resolve here on a deed of settlement basis;
- Test cases: consider lodging a test case where multiple group entities face similar assessments;
- Costs: the TRAB and TRAT have jurisdiction to award costs; large unsuccessful appeals can be expensive on this front;
- Speed: a full run from TRAB to Court of Appeal can take three to five years — early-stage strategy is the difference between resolution and attrition.
How RIVE & Co. Adds Value
RIVE & Co.’s tax disputes practice handles end-to-end representation through the full appeals chain. We draft persuasive grounds of appeal, lead expert witnesses on transfer pricing and valuation issues, conduct cross-examination, and argue points of law before the Court of Appeal of Tanzania.
Considering an appeal against a TRA decision?
Contact me at sunday@rive.co.tz for an early case assessment.
