Litigation through TRAB, TRAT and the Court of Appeal of Tanzania can take five years or more. For most commercial taxpayers, the cost of capital tied up in a one-third deposit, the management distraction, and the uncertainty of outcome make settlement a far more compelling option than a public trial. Tanzanian law now supports several settlement pathways, each with distinct legal consequences.

Three Settlement Pathways Under Tanzanian Law

1. The Proposal Letter (Section 52 of the Tax Administration Act)

While considering a Notice of Objection, the Commissioner General may issue a proposal letter setting out a position the TRA is willing to accept. Under amendments introduced by the Finance Act, 2024, where the Commissioner issues such a letter before the expiry of the six-month determination window, the position in the letter is treated as the objection decision if accepted (or, where the taxpayer fails to respond, deemed to be the objection decision).

This makes the proposal letter a de facto early-stage settlement instrument. Engagement at this stage is high-leverage; ignoring a proposal letter is the costliest mistake a taxpayer can make.

2. Mediation at the TRAB / TRAT Stage (Finance Act, 2021)

The Finance Act, 2021 introduced an out-of-court mediation pathway available at the TRAB and TRAT levels. A taxpayer with a pending appeal may, with the consent of the TRA, engage in structured mediation. If mediation succeeds, the resolution is reduced to a deed of settlement registered with the Board or Tribunal — and the deed has the binding force of a final judgment.

The 2024 reforms have introduced clearer timelines for mediation, addressing the earlier criticism that the process could be left indefinitely open.

3. Direct Negotiated Settlement

Outside the formal mediation framework, taxpayers and the TRA frequently negotiate at any stage of a dispute. These settlements are typically captured in a written agreement and given effect through an adjusted assessment under section 48 of the Tax Administration Act.

What Makes a Tax Settlement Stick?

A settlement only delivers value if it:

  • Is reduced to writing and signed by an officer with binding authority on behalf of the Commissioner General;
  • Identifies precisely the years of income, tax heads, and disputed items it covers;
  • Provides for a corresponding adjusted assessment to issue;
  • Releases the taxpayer from interest and penalties on the settled amounts (and, where possible, secures a non-pursuit covenant for the same matters);
  • Is final and not subject to re-opening absent fraud — a point the Tax Revenue Appeals Act expressly preserves under section 17.

When Settlement Is Wise — and When It Is Not

Settle when:

  • The legal position is finely balanced and the cost of litigation outweighs the disputed sum;
  • The dispute is fact-heavy and turns on documents that may struggle in cross-examination;
  • Reputation, ongoing licensing, or M&A considerations make a public dispute unattractive;
  • The TRA’s offer represents a genuine economic improvement on the worst-case litigated outcome.

Litigate when:

  • The dispute concerns a recurring item that will arise in future years (a settlement may not bind future assessments);
  • A favourable Court of Appeal precedent would benefit the wider industry — such cases generate sectoral leadership for the taxpayer;
  • The TRA’s position is plainly contrary to a binding authority.

The Role of Penalties and Interest in Settlement

Interest on late tax payments is charged at the Bank of Tanzania discount rate plus 5%, compounded monthly — currently in the 12–15% per annum range. In long-running disputes, interest can exceed the principal. Any well-structured settlement must explicitly address penalty remission and interest computation, and where possible, secure remission applications under the Tax Administration Act.

RIVE & Co.’s Settlement Practice

RIVE & Co. has negotiated and reduced to deed of settlement some of Tanzania’s most significant tax disputes for clients in mining, banking, telecoms and consumer goods. We combine commercial deal-making instinct with rigorous tax-law analysis to extract the best achievable outcome — and to ensure the settlement is genuinely final.

Considering settlement of a TRA dispute?
Email sunday@rive.co.tz for a strategic assessment of your options.


Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The law is stated as at the date of publication and may change. Readers should seek specific legal advice before acting on any matter discussed. RIVE & Co. and the author accept no liability for action taken or not taken on the basis of this publication.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *